Skip to main content

Response to Neil de Grasse Tyson on GMOs

Recently I saw a post from business insider of Prof. Neil de Grasse Tyson talking about GMOs. He says: 
What most people don't know, but they should, is that practically every food you buy in a store for consumption by humans is genetically modified food.
There are no wild seedless watermelons; there's no wild cows; there's no long-stem roses growing in the wild — although we don't eat roses. You list all the fruit, and all the vegetables, and ask yourself: Is there a wild counterpart to this? If there is, it's not as large, it's not as sweet, it's not as juicy, and it has way more seeds in it. 
We have systematically genetically modified all the foods, the vegetables and animals, that we have eaten ever since we cultivated them. It's called "artificial selection." That's how we genetically modify them. So now that we can do it in a lab, all of a sudden you're going to complain?


I've heard those arguments before. And though I think Prof. Tyson is brilliant, he's no biologist. Physicist tend to have problems with Biology quite often, mainly due to the precision that exists in Physics but is absent from Biology. 

He is correct that almost all our food has been "genetically-modified" through artificial selection, but this process mimics the natural selection, it's much slower and doesn't introduce genes from other animals. What GMO's are is totally different. They are novel processes that introduce genes not found in the host organism from another. Typically this is done through using a disabled virus as a vector. Very different. And while I am pretty sure most are safe(ish) to eat, that's not what worries me most about franken food. It's their impact on ecology. 

Besides we still don't know how nutrition works. I'd be very careful with what I recommend is safe in terms of food. Other lab foods like margarine, sorbitol, olestra, and saccharine (once linked to cancer) have been found to have unanticipated side effects much later on.

p.s. 
I looked up saccharine and it turns out they removed the label that it causes cancer in 2000. That's interesting. Saccharine causes cancer in rodents but not necessarily humans. It only took over 20 years to figure that out. Shows how little we know of how nutrition work. 

By the way, margarine originally had lots of trans-fats that could cause heart problems due to cholesterol, sorbitol can cause irritable bowel syndrome and olestra diarrhea. All fun stuff.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Multiple Assignments in Ruby

In this Rails project I'm running I need to set a whole bunch of individual variables to 'disabled' at once depending on the group the current user belongs to. We can use multiple assignment in this case but with a caveat. Multiple assignments are a quick way of setting a lot of variables at once. h, k = 1,2  => [1,2] h => 1 k => 2 but   h, k = 1      => 1 h => 1 k => nil In that case we can do this: h = k = 1   => 1 h => 1 h => 1  Beware this sets them to the same object. So if you change one you change both. h = k = [] h << 1 h => [1] k => [1] While we're at it here is how to reverse two variables: h = 1 k = 2 h,k = k,h h => 2 k => 1

What Medieval Economics can teach us about tariffs.

As a teen, I used to play Dungeons and Dragons (D&D) with my friends. This started an interest in the medieval period that led to me taking a medieval history class in college just to understand the period more. Over the years I've also read great books like " Dungeon, Fire and Sword " about the crusades (I recommend the book) and yet with all that knowledge it wasn't until recently that it occurred to me I had a completely wrong understanding of economics in the Medieval Period. "Viking helmets, sword and footwear" by eltpics is licensed under CC BY-NC 2.0 In my D&D games, players who are adventures battling monsters and creatures would need equipment and on the trips to town, they'd get resupplied with their adventuring necessities. I'd run these moments referencing my imagination of what it must have been and fantasy books I'd read. There be an inn with a raucous bar, a gruffly black-smith, if a city also a weapon and armor sm...

Setting up the Marble Mouse for Ubuntu

I have a Logitech trackball which I love. I bought it when my wrists started hurting after hours of long Photoshop sessions. The switch to the trackball fixed all that. It allows me to hold my hand in the perfect position and it's great for most browsing with one exception: It lacks a middle-click wheel. This presents a bigger problem than it seems, as design seems to be removing the scroll bars at the edges of windows in favor of small slits. So to get around this you can emulate a scroll wheel or use the middle click to activate a scroll motion on various programs. Logitech has a utility that sets this up in Windows but in Ubuntu you have a better (if more hard-work required) option. The Ubuntu option is better because unlike in Windows you can emulate the wheel with the track-ball by holding down a button. This is the option I like to use. In Ubuntu you write a configuration file to set up the trackball to work the way you want it. I have to re-create this...