Skip to main content

Amazon's A-B Testing and Government Applications

One of the benefits of scientific research is that by being empirical or experimentally driven it avoids circular and endless discussions on what works or should work. You can just check it. You test to see what works. Jeff Bezos described in a Stanford lecture how Amazon utilizes this testing in it's site live to verify improvements. The ability to test which option is best increases efficiency as it cuts down not only on inefficient options but also on the time that would have been spent discussing the pros and cons of each approach. At Amazon this approach is called A-B testing. Where one option "A" is tested against option "B" and the results are seen immediately. This data-driven approach is what makes science edge out over other disciplines, and it's one that seems sorely lacking on the social sciences, where argument rather than data still reigns king. It doesn't matter that "trickle down economics" didn't have it's intended effect if the data is analyzed, what matters is that the argument sounds right and wins out over it's opposition.

I think it's high time that this data-driven approach be brought to our public institutions like government. In Amazon's elegant A-B testing approach (possibly with the addition of a C control) would be fantastic to test approaches with real data as opposed to talking heads on congress or the media. Think about simple things such as tax laws. Imagine if instead of it being driven by mere legislators it was goal driven and experimentally tested. Many laws fail in its intended purpose because debate or rationally doesn't drive human behavior. We are emotional creatures and not driven by cool dispassionate reason. Society's glorification of reason is a offspring of the Enlightenment the period that saw the birth of the nation of the United States. The Enlightenment which held reason above the then wide authority of the church, found liberty and practicality in its look at rationality. But now we're hitting the limits of such view. We are seeing the failure of reason. We need to use experimentation more. Forget about what "should" work and see what actually does work. What's great is that this is being used by businesses now. We don't have to invent it. Amazon does it with it's A-B testing and gets real time results. Can't we do it with laws too? How much easier would it be to vote on which tax law to approve or which ballot initiative if the data was already in? It may be hard to convince someone that changing something can be beneficial without this data but far more dangerous are things that sound rationally right but experimentally fail to accomplish their set goals, like the supposed "benefit" of trickle down economics.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Multiple Assignments in Ruby

In this Rails project I'm running I need to set a whole bunch of individual variables to 'disabled' at once depending on the group the current user belongs to. We can use multiple assignment in this case but with a caveat. Multiple assignments are a quick way of setting a lot of variables at once. h, k = 1,2  => [1,2] h => 1 k => 2 but   h, k = 1      => 1 h => 1 k => nil In that case we can do this: h = k = 1   => 1 h => 1 h => 1  Beware this sets them to the same object. So if you change one you change both. h = k = [] h << 1 h => [1] k => [1] While we're at it here is how to reverse two variables: h = 1 k = 2 h,k = k,h h => 2 k => 1
Post a Comment
Read more

What Medieval Economics can teach us about tariffs.

As a teen, I used to play Dungeons and Dragons (D&D) with my friends. This started an interest in the medieval period that led to me taking a medieval history class in college just to understand the period more. Over the years I've also read great books like " Dungeon, Fire and Sword " about the crusades (I recommend the book) and yet with all that knowledge it wasn't until recently that it occurred to me I had a completely wrong understanding of economics in the Medieval Period. "Viking helmets, sword and footwear" by eltpics is licensed under CC BY-NC 2.0 In my D&D games, players who are adventures battling monsters and creatures would need equipment and on the trips to town, they'd get resupplied with their adventuring necessities. I'd run these moments referencing my imagination of what it must have been and fantasy books I'd read. There be an inn with a raucous bar, a gruffly black-smith, if a city also a weapon and armor sm...
Post a Comment
Read more

Setting up the Marble Mouse for Ubuntu

I have a Logitech trackball which I love. I bought it when my wrists started hurting after hours of long Photoshop sessions. The switch to the trackball fixed all that. It allows me to hold my hand in the perfect position and it's great for most browsing with one exception: It lacks a middle-click wheel. This presents a bigger problem than it seems, as design seems to be removing the scroll bars at the edges of windows in favor of small slits. So to get around this you can emulate a scroll wheel or use the middle click to activate a scroll motion on various programs. Logitech has a utility that sets this up in Windows but in Ubuntu you have a better (if more hard-work required) option. The Ubuntu option is better because unlike in Windows you can emulate the wheel with the track-ball by holding down a button. This is the option I like to use. In Ubuntu you write a configuration file to set up the trackball to work the way you want it. I have to re-create this...
3 comments
Read more